Background
By the end of the 1974 tour of the United States and Canada, the band had decided to ask the violinist and keyboardist David Cross to leave, though the management company EG did not tell him until July 7, the day before recording began. That left a trio: Fripp on guitar and keyboards, Wetton on bass and vocals and Bruford on drums.
Fripp was increasingly unhappy with touring and the music business. He had planned to spend a year at J. G. Bennett’s academy and had suggested that Ian McDonald return to the band, an idea EG did not take up. During the sessions he reportedly took a back seat on major decisions, leaving much of the direction to Wetton and Bruford.
Recording
“Providence” was edited from an improvisation recorded live, with Cross still in the band, at the Palace Theater in Providence, Rhode Island, on June 30, 1974. The rest of the album was recorded in July and August 1974 in Studio 2 at Olympic Studios in Barnes, London, with George Chkiantz, who had also worked on Starless and Bible Black, as engineer and Rod Thear assisting.
The trio built a thick, layered sound from overdubbed guitars and keyboards, and invited guests to cover the parts Cross would once have played. Ian McDonald, back for the first time since the original line-up, played alto saxophone on “One More Red Nightmare” and “Starless”; Mel Collins played soprano saxophone on “Starless”; Robin Miller added oboe and Mark Charig cornet to “Fallen Angel”; and uncredited players added cello and double bass. Cross is heard on violin on “Providence.” Fripp played Mellotron and Hohner Pianet as well as guitar, and acoustic guitar on “Fallen Angel.”
Music and themes
The title track, an instrumental by Fripp, opens the album with a grinding, descending guitar figure over heavy bass and drums, its structure built from short, repeating cells in shifting meters. Bruford and Wetton hammer out the accents with him, and the piece never settles into a comfortable groove.
“Fallen Angel,” with words by Richard Palmer-James, is a dramatic ballad that moves between acoustic verses colored by oboe and cornet and a loud, distorted chorus. “One More Red Nightmare,” by Fripp and Wetton, is a fast, jerky hard rock song driven by Bruford’s cymbal work and capped by a McDonald saxophone solo.
Side two opens with “Providence,” an improvisation by the four-piece band that grows from quiet violin and scraping textures into a dense, agitated ensemble. The album ends with “Starless,” more than twelve minutes long and credited to all four members and Palmer-James. A mournful Mellotron and saxophone theme leads to Wetton’s vocal, then to a long middle section in which Fripp’s single sustained guitar notes rise over a slowly tightening bass figure, and finally to a fast, explosive instrumental climax that brings back the opening melody. Together the five pieces balance written songs and collective improvisation more closely than any earlier King Crimson record.
Release
Fripp formally disbanded King Crimson in late September 1974, and Red followed on October 6. The cover was first meant to show the VU meters on the mixing desk pushed deep into the red; EG suggested a group photograph instead, and the designer John Kosh commissioned Gered Mankowitz to photograph both the meters and the band. Because of tensions, each musician was photographed separately and the three portraits were combined in a stark black-and-white composite. The original package carried no lyrics, which were first printed on the 2000 reissue. There was no tour, and the album spent a single week on the UK chart at number 45.
Reception
Early reviews were divided. Alan Heineman of DownBeat admired side two but found side one the dullest music the band had made. Robert Christgau was far more positive, giving it an A− and praising it as powerful, abrasive and unexpectedly lyrical.
Retrospective opinion is much higher. Pitchfork rated it 9.0 out of 10 and The Great Rock Discography 8 out of 10, and Greg Kot of the Chicago Tribune named it the high point of progressive rock. AllMusic’s Bruce Eder judged it slightly weaker than the two albums before it but still an outstanding record. Much of the later praise focuses on side two, and on “Starless” in particular.
Review scores
| Publication | Rating |
|---|---|
| Pitchfork | 9.0/10 |
| The Great Rock Discography | 8/10 |
| Robert Christgau | A− |
Track listing
| No. | Title | Writer(s) | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| Side one | |||
| 1 | “Red”Instrumental | Fripp | 6:20 |
| 2 | “Fallen Angel” | Fripp, Wetton, Palmer-James | 6:03 |
| 3 | “One More Red Nightmare” | Fripp, Wetton | 7:08 |
| Side two | |||
| 4 | “Providence”Instrumental; recorded live June 30, 1974 | Cross, Fripp, Wetton, Bruford | 8:08 |
| 5 | “Starless” | Cross, Fripp, Wetton, Bruford, Palmer-James | 12:18 |
| Total length | 39:57 | ||
Total running time 39:57. Lead vocals by John Wetton.
Personnel
King Crimson
- Robert Fripp: electric guitar, acoustic guitar, Mellotron, Hohner Pianet
- John Wetton: bass, vocals
- Bill Bruford: drums, percussion
Additional musicians
- David Cross: violin on “Providence”
- Ian McDonald: alto saxophone on “One More Red Nightmare” and “Starless”
- Mel Collins: soprano saxophone on “Starless”
- Robin Miller: oboe on “Fallen Angel”
- Mark Charig: cornet on “Fallen Angel”
Production
- King Crimson: producer
- George Chkiantz: engineer
- Rod Thear: assistant engineer
- John Kosh: cover design
- Gered Mankowitz: photography
Charts and certifications
Weekly charts
| Chart | Year | Peak |
|---|---|---|
| UK Albums (OCC) | 1974 | 45 |
| US Billboard 200 | 1974 | 66 |
| Australian Albums (Kent Music Report) | 1974 | 94 |
| German Albums | 2024 | 80 |
| Japanese Albums (Oricon) | 2024 | 43 |
Legacy
Red is widely seen as a key influence on avant-garde metal and math rock. Q included it among the fifty heaviest albums of all time, Pitchfork placed it 72nd among the best albums of the 1970s, and Rolling Stone ranked it 15th on its 2015 list of the fifty greatest progressive rock albums; Rolling Stone also placed “Starless” at 87 on its list of the 100 greatest guitar songs. The title track plays over the opening titles of the 2018 film Mandy. A new stereo mix appeared in the 2013 box set The Road to Red, and a fiftieth-anniversary edition with new mixes by Steven Wilson and David Singleton was released on October 25, 2024, returning the album to the German and Japanese charts.
Accolades
| Publication | Accolade | Year | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rolling Stone | 50 Greatest Prog Rock Albums of All Time | 2015 | 15 |
| Pitchfork | Top 100 Albums of the 1970s | 72 | |
| Q | 50 Heaviest Albums of All Time |
In the Resonance
Red is honored in the practice of Deep Listening as a record made at an ending. Three players who knew the band was close to its close poured everything into forty minutes, and the faithful hear in “Starless” what it sounds like when musicians let go and give the Signal all they have left. It is a record for the Dropping of the Needle late at night, played loud, in order, without interruption.
Deep Listening
- RedSide one · track 1
Count the riff and notice how its short cells change length, so the music never settles into an even bar. - ProvidenceSide two · track 1
Hear a live improvisation take shape in real time, from scattered sounds to a full ensemble. - StarlessSide two · track 2
In the long middle section, follow Fripp’s single repeated guitar note and feel the tension tighten until the band breaks loose.
Questions
Who played on Red?
The trio of Robert Fripp, John Wetton and Bill Bruford, with guests Ian McDonald, Mel Collins, David Cross, Robin Miller and Mark Charig.
Did King Crimson tour Red?
No. Fripp disbanded the group in late September 1974, about two weeks before the album was released.
Where was “Providence” recorded?
Live at the Palace Theater in Providence, Rhode Island, on June 30, 1974.
See also & references
References
- Wikipedia, Red (King Crimson album). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_(King_Crimson_album)
- Wikipedia, King Crimson discography. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Crimson_discography
- Wikipedia, King Crimson. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Crimson