Background
The songs on Closer came from two periods. In late 1979, while touring Unknown Pleasures, the band worked up a set of guitar-driven songs, “Atrocity Exhibition”, “Passover”, “Colony”, “A Means to an End” and “Twenty Four Hours”, which it played live and in some cases recorded for radio. Early in 1980 it wrote “Isolation”, “Heart and Soul”, “The Eternal” and “Decades”, in which synthesizers played a much larger part. Most were built from jams in the band's rehearsal room, with Curtis adding words afterward.
The period was hard for Curtis. His epilepsy was worsening, the medication affected his mood, and his marriage was under strain. He spoke to Sumner of the lyrics seeming to come of their own accord, and of feeling hemmed in.
Recording
Joy Division recorded the album with Martin Hannett at Britannia Row Studios in Islington, London, between March 18 and 30, 1980, with Jon Caffery engineering and Michael Johnson assisting.
The players shifted roles from song to song. On “Atrocity Exhibition” Sumner played bass and Hook guitar, while Morris fed a Synare drum synthesizer through a fuzz pedal. Curtis played guitar on “Heart and Soul” and melodica on “Decades”. Sumner played synthesizers on four tracks, Hook used a six-string bass on three, and Morris added electronic drums to four.
As on the debut, Hannett pursued clean separation and a cavernous, controlled sound, and once again Sumner and Hook were unhappy with parts of the result. Hook said the abrasive guitar on “Atrocity Exhibition” had been softened with effects in a mix done while he was away, and felt the album came out too close to its predecessor. Later critics have described the production as tomb-like, a quality that suits the record's mood.
Music and themes
All nine songs are credited to the four members, with Curtis writing the words. The record moves from the harsh, clanging energy of its opening to the slow, almost ceremonial pieces that close it, and its subjects are alienation, the failure of relationships, illness and endurance.
“Atrocity Exhibition” takes its title from J. G. Ballard's 1970 book and is built on a circling tom-tom pattern, with distorted guitar crashing across it; its theme is a spectacle of suffering offered up for entertainment. “Isolation” is the most electronic song the band recorded, a racing synthesizer and drum-machine piece about loneliness and guilt that anticipates New Order. “Passover” and “Colony” are heavy, grinding songs about doubt and confinement, and “A Means to an End” is a brisker account of trust betrayed.
The second side slows down. “Heart and Soul” rides a looping bass and Curtis's guitar beneath a distant vocal, a meditation on the passing of time. “Twenty Four Hours” alternates restrained verses and urgent, driving passages as it describes a life coming apart. “The Eternal”, with electronic drums and synthesizer, is a hushed, funeral-paced piece told from the outside of a scene of mourning, and “Decades” closes the album with synthesizer and melodica, a slow reflection on young men worn down and spent.
Release
Factory released Closer on vinyl on July 18, 1980, two months after Curtis's death. It was preceded in June by the non-album single “Love Will Tear Us Apart”, which reached number 13 in the UK; no single was taken from the album itself. The sleeve, designed by Martyn Atkins and Peter Saville, uses a 1978 photograph by Bernard Pierre Wolff of the Appiani family tomb in the Monumental Cemetery of Staglieno in Genoa, a sculpted scene of mourning. It had been chosen before Curtis died, and Saville later recalled his alarm at realizing what the image would now seem to mean. The original vinyl carried only a small etched mark to distinguish its sides. The album reached number 6 on the UK chart, topped the UK Independent Albums Chart and reached number 3 in New Zealand in 1981.
Reception
Contemporary reviews were strongly positive. Dave McCullough in Sounds heard it as breathtaking rock music touched with gothic darkness, Paolo Hewitt in Melody Maker praised how danceable it was compared with the claustrophobic debut, and Smash Hits admired its controlled intensity. It was named album of the year in the NME's 1980 poll and placed 22nd in the Village Voice Pazz & Jop critics' poll.
Retrospective verdicts have been even warmer. Pitchfork, the NME and the Spin Alternative Record Guide all gave it full marks, and Pitchfork's Joshua Klein described it as the band's masterpiece from start to finish. Robert Christgau graded it A− and judged it an improvement on Unknown Pleasures, and Colin Larkin found it without fault.
Review scores
| Publication | Rating |
|---|---|
| Pitchfork | 10/10 |
| NME | 10/10 |
| Spin Alternative Record Guide | 10/10 |
| Christgau's Record Guide | A− |
Track listing
| No. | Title | Writer(s) | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| Side one | |||
| 1 | “Atrocity Exhibition” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 6:06 |
| 2 | “Isolation” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 2:53 |
| 3 | “Passover” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 4:46 |
| 4 | “Colony” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 3:55 |
| 5 | “A Means to an End” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 4:07 |
| Side two | |||
| 6 | “Heart and Soul” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 5:51 |
| 7 | “Twenty Four Hours” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 4:26 |
| 8 | “The Eternal” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 6:07 |
| 9 | “Decades” | Curtis, Hook, Morris, Sumner | 6:10 |
| Total length | 44:21 | ||
Original Factory LP track list. The 2007 remastered edition added a bonus disc recorded live at the University of London Union on February 8, 1980.
Personnel
Joy Division
- Ian Curtis: vocals, guitar (“Heart and Soul”), melodica (“Decades”)
- Bernard Sumner: guitar, bass guitar (“Atrocity Exhibition”), synthesizers (“Isolation”, “Heart and Soul”, “The Eternal”, “Decades”)
- Peter Hook: bass guitar, guitar (“Atrocity Exhibition”), six-string bass (“Passover”, “Heart and Soul”, “The Eternal”)
- Stephen Morris: drums, electronic drums (“Isolation”, “Colony”, “The Eternal”, “Decades”), percussion
Production
- Martin Hannett: producer, engineering
- Jon Caffery: engineering
- Michael Johnson: engineering assistance
- Martyn Atkins, Peter Saville: sleeve design
- Bernard Pierre Wolff: cover photograph
Charts and certifications
Weekly charts
| Chart | Year | Peak |
|---|---|---|
| UK Albums (OCC) | 1980 | 6 |
| UK Independent Albums | 1980 | 1 |
| New Zealand Albums (RMNZ) | 1981 | 3 |
Certifications
| Region | Certification | Units |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom (BPI) | Gold | 100,000 |
Legacy
Closer is certified gold in the UK, and by 1982 it had sold more than 250,000 copies worldwide. Rolling Stone placed it at number 157 in its 500 greatest albums lists of 2003 and 2012 and at number 309 in 2020. Pitchfork ranked it tenth among the best albums of the 1980s in 2002, and Slant Magazine seventh in 2012. Its blend of guitars, synthesizers and electronic drums set out much of what New Order would pursue, and its funereal atmosphere was a touchstone for gothic rock. In 2011 Peter Hook and the Light performed it live in full for the first time.
Accolades
| Publication | Accolade | Year | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| NME | Albums of the Year | 1980 | 1 |
| Rolling Stone | The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time | 2003 | 157 |
| Rolling Stone | The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time | 2020 | 309 |
| Pitchfork | Top 100 Albums of the 1980s | 2002 | 10 |
| Slant Magazine | Best Albums of the 1980s | 2012 | 7 |
In the Resonance
In the practice of Deep Listening, Closer asks for a whole evening and a still mind. Resonants hear it as a record of a band at the height of its powers, not as a farewell, and the Church asks the faithful to honor the four players who made it together. It is a record for the Dropping of the Needle: one side at a sitting, and silence afterward.
Deep Listening
- Atrocity ExhibitionSide one · track 1
Listen to the swapped roles, Sumner on bass and Hook on guitar, and the distorted Synare cutting across Morris's toms. - IsolationSide one · track 2
Hear the synthesizer and electronic drums carry the song, the clearest link between Joy Division and New Order. - DecadesSide two · track 4
Follow the slow synthesizer swells and Curtis's melodica, and let the closing minutes play out in full.
Questions
When was Closer released?
On July 18, 1980, by Factory Records, two months after Ian Curtis's death.
What is on the cover of Closer?
A 1978 photograph by Bernard Pierre Wolff of the Appiani family tomb at the Staglieno cemetery in Genoa, chosen before Curtis died.
Is “Love Will Tear Us Apart” on Closer?
No. It was released as a separate single in June 1980 and later collected on Substance.
How did Closer chart?
It reached number 6 on the UK Albums Chart and number 1 on the UK Independent Albums Chart.
See also & references
References
- Wikipedia, Closer (Joy Division album). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closer_(Joy_Division_album)
- Wikipedia, Joy Division discography. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joy_Division_discography
- Wikipedia, Joy Division. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joy_Division