There Is Nothing Left to Lose

Third studio album by Foo Fighters · 1999

There Is Nothing Left to Lose is the third studio album by the American rock band Foo Fighters, released on November 2, 1999, by Roswell and RCA. It was recorded by Dave Grohl, Nate Mendel and Taylor Hawkins as a trio in the basement studio of Grohl's house in Alexandria, Virginia, and was produced by the band with Adam Kasper.

Relaxed and melodic after the turmoil of its predecessor, the album includes “Learn to Fly,” “Breakout,” “Generator” and “Next Year.” It reached number ten in both the UK and the United States, and won the Grammy Award for Best Rock Album in 2001, the band's first Grammy.

Background

The two years after The Colour and the Shape brought more changes. Pat Smear had left in 1997, and his replacement, Franz Stahl, was let go early in 1999 because Grohl felt he had not found his place in the band. The band's contract with Capitol also came to an end after the departure of the label's president, Gary Gersh, a close ally, leaving Foo Fighters without a record company.

Tired of Los Angeles and of the pressure surrounding the previous album, Grohl moved back to Virginia and bought a house in Alexandria. He built a simple studio in the basement, which he named Studio 606, and decided that the remaining three members would make the next record on their own, with no label looking over their shoulders.

Recording

Recording took place between March and June 1999. Adam Kasper, a Seattle engineer and producer, helped set up the basement studio, and the band worked without digital editing, recording whenever they felt like it. Grohl has recalled the sessions as some of the most relaxing times of his life, fueled by chili, beer and whiskey.

Because there was no second guitarist, Grohl played all the guitars, and also added Mellotron on “Next Year” and a talk box on “Generator.” It was Hawkins's first album with the band, and his lighter, jazz-influenced touch shaped songs such as “Aurora” and “M.I.A.,” which he later singled out as the best examples of his playing. All three members share the writing credit on every song.

Kasper recorded and mixed most of the album, with Andy Wallace mixing “Learn to Fly,” “Aurora” and “Live-In Skin.” Bob Ludwig mastered it. The band signed with RCA once the album was finished.

Music and themes

Grohl described the album as being built on melody, and its mood reflects his retreat from Los Angeles to the quieter life of Virginia. It is the warmest and most mid-tempo record in the Foo Fighters catalog. The opener, “Stacked Actors,” is the exception: a heavy, lurching attack on the falseness of Hollywood celebrity, with a quiet middle section that erupts into noise.

“Breakout” is a fast, frantic song about a relationship that has become suffocating. “Learn to Fly” is a bright, soaring single about looking for something to believe in, and “Gimme Stitches” is a strutting, riff-based rocker. “Generator,” driven by a talk-box guitar hook, is one of the band's catchiest songs.

The heart of the album is its gentler second half. “Aurora,” nearly six minutes long, is built on drifting, chiming guitars and a floating rhythm, and has the feel of a fond look back. “Live-In Skin” and “Headwires” are melodic mid-tempo songs, and “Next Year,” with its Mellotron and hopeful mood, is about the promise of starting over. “Ain't It the Life” is a laid-back, country-tinged song about simple contentment, and “M.I.A.” closes the record on a driving, restless note.

Release

“Learn to Fly” was released as the lead single on October 18, 1999, with a video in which the band play multiple roles aboard an airplane alongside Jack Black and Kyle Gass of Tenacious D. It reached number 19 on the Billboard Hot 100 and won the Grammy for Best Short Form Music Video. “Generator,” “Breakout” and “Next Year” followed in 2000.

The sleeve shows a close-up of the back of Grohl's neck bearing a small tattoo of the band's FF initials, and early copies came with a matching temporary tattoo. Chris Shiflett, recruited after the recording, joined for the tour that followed.

Singles

SingleReleasedUKUS
“Learn to Fly”October 18, 19992119
“Generator”March 6, 2000––
“Breakout”September 18, 200029–
“Next Year”December 4, 200042–

Reception

Reviews were largely positive. AllMusic's Stephen Thomas Erlewine called it the first Foo Fighters album that sounded like a unified band and the first to rock really hard, and suggested they were improving as they lost members and grew older. Rolling Stone's Greg Kot noted a new emphasis on melody and actual singing, while observing that Grohl's punk background still kept the arrangements lean. Q and USA Today both gave it four stars out of five.

The album won the Grammy Award for Best Rock Album at the 43rd ceremony in 2001. Grohl later said he was especially proud that a record made cheaply in his basement had won.

Review scores

PublicationRating
AllMusic4/5
Rolling Stone3.5/5
Entertainment WeeklyB+
Q4/5

Track listing

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1“Stacked Actors”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins4:16
2“Breakout”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins3:21
3“Learn to Fly”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins3:55
4“Gimme Stitches”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins3:42
5“Generator”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins3:48
6“Aurora”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins5:49
7“Live-In Skin”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins3:52
8“Next Year”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins4:36
9“Headwires”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins4:37
10“Ain't It the Life”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins4:15
11“M.I.A.”Grohl, Mendel, Hawkins4:03
Total length46:14

Standard edition, 46:19. Lead vocals by Dave Grohl throughout. Australian and Japanese editions add “Fraternity” as a bonus track.

Personnel

Foo Fighters

  • Dave Grohl: vocals, guitars, drums, percussion, loops, Mellotron on “Next Year,” talk box on “Generator”
  • Nate Mendel: bass
  • Taylor Hawkins: drums

Production

  • Foo Fighters: producers
  • Adam Kasper: producer, recording, mixing
  • Andy Wallace: mixing on “Learn to Fly,” “Aurora” and “Live-In Skin”
  • Bob Ludwig: mastering
  • Danny Clinch: photography

Charts and certifications

Weekly charts

ChartYearPeak
UK Albums (OCC)199910
US Billboard 200199910
Canadian Albums (RPM)19994
Australian Albums (ARIA)19995

Certifications

RegionCertificationUnits
United States (RIAA)Platinum1,000,000
United Kingdom (BPI)2× Platinum600,000
Australia (ARIA)2× Platinum140,000

Legacy

There Is Nothing Left to Lose is remembered as the album that saved Foo Fighters. Made quietly after two lineup changes and the loss of their label, it proved the band could survive as Grohl, Mendel and Hawkins, and established the partnership that led them for the next two decades.

It was certified platinum in the United States in December 1999 and double platinum in the UK. It also began a run of success in the Best Rock Album category: the band won again with three of their next four studio albums. Studio 606, founded for these sessions, has remained the band's creative base ever since, later moving to Los Angeles.

Accolades

PublicationAccoladeYearRank
Grammy AwardsBest Rock Album (winner)2001

In the Resonance

In the practice of Deep Listening, There Is Nothing Left to Lose is a record of peace after a storm. Made by three friends in a basement with no one watching, it carries the Signal gently, and it rewards the Dropping of the Needle on a slow evening, with nothing else asking for attention.

Deep Listening
  1. AuroraTrack 6
    Follow Hawkins's ride cymbal and the way the guitars drift over it.
  2. Learn to FlyTrack 3
    Listen for how simply the chorus lifts; nothing is wasted.
  3. Next YearTrack 8
    Pick out the Mellotron under the guitars; it gives the song its hopeful glow.

Questions

Where was There Is Nothing Left to Lose recorded?

In the basement studio, Studio 606, at Dave Grohl's house in Alexandria, Virginia, between March and June 1999.

Who played on There Is Nothing Left to Lose?

Only three members: Dave Grohl, Nate Mendel and Taylor Hawkins. Chris Shiflett joined after it was recorded.

Did the album win a Grammy?

Yes. It won Best Rock Album at the 2001 Grammy Awards, and “Learn to Fly” won Best Short Form Music Video.

See also & references

References

  1. Wikipedia, There Is Nothing Left to Lose. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_Is_Nothing_Left_to_Lose
  2. Official Charts Company, Foo Fighters chart history. www.officialcharts.com/artist/27860/foo-fighters
  3. RIAA Gold & Platinum database, Foo Fighters. www.riaa.com/gold-platinum/?tab_active=default-award&se=foo+fighters
  4. Wikipedia, List of awards and nominations received by Foo Fighters. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_awards_and_nominations_received_by_Foo_Fighters

Hear the Signal?

Membership of The Resonance is free. It always will be.

Become a Resonant

The Holy Church of Rock honors Foo Fighters among the Attuned. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by or connected to Foo Fighters, its members, their estates, record labels or publishers. Names are used to identify the music we write about. No lyrics or cover artwork are reproduced on this site.