What’s Going On

Eleventh studio album by Marvin Gaye · 1971

What's Going On is the eleventh studio album by the American soul singer Marvin Gaye, released on May 21, 1971, by Motown's Tamla label. The first album Gaye produced himself, it is a song cycle that loosely follows a Vietnam veteran coming home to a country troubled by war, poverty, addiction and damage to the environment, with its songs flowing into one another like the movements of a suite.

The album reached number six on the Billboard 200 and spent nine weeks at number one on the soul albums chart, and its three American singles, “What's Going On,” “Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)” and “Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler),” all reached the Hot 100 top ten. It is widely considered one of the greatest albums ever made, and in 2020 Rolling Stone ranked it number one on its list of the 500 greatest albums of all time.

Background

By 1970 Gaye was one of Motown's most successful singers but felt confined by a system in which staff writers and producers shaped the records and the artist supplied the voice. Tammi Terrell's illness and death in March 1970 left him depressed and unwilling to perform. Letters from his brother Frankie, then serving in Vietnam, and Frankie's accounts of the war when the two met again in Washington moved him deeply, and he later named the 1965 Watts riots as a turning point in his thinking. For a time he even pursued a tryout with the Detroit Lions, befriending the players Mel Farr, Lem Barney and Charlie Sanders, before giving up the idea.

The spark came from Renaldo “Obie” Benson of the Four Tops, who had seen police violence against anti-war protesters at People's Park in Berkeley in May 1969. With the songwriter Al Cleveland he wrote a song about it, which the Four Tops turned down. Benson offered it to Gaye, who reworked the melody and words and took a share of the writing credit. Berry Gordy at first refused to release the result, believing it too political for radio, and Gaye declined to record anything else until the label relented.

Recording

The title track came first. Its basic track was cut at Hitsville U.S.A.'s Studio A in Detroit on June 1, 1970, with overdubs in July at Studio B, the former Golden World studio, and strings added on September 21. Released as a single in January 1971, it was an immediate hit, and Motown asked for an album. Gaye recorded the rest of the record quickly: basic tracks on March 17, 19 and 20, 1971, and overdubs later that month at Hitsville and Golden World, with United Sound Studios possibly used for overflow.

The music was played by Motown's house musicians, the Funk Brothers, among them bassist James Jamerson, percussionists Jack Ashford and Eddie Brown, and drummer Chet Forest, with Bob Babbitt on bass for “Mercy Mercy Me” and “Inner City Blues.” David Van De Pitte wrote and conducted the orchestral arrangements, including the bass parts that Jamerson reportedly played lying on the floor. The alto saxophone that opens the album was an unplanned take by Eli Fontaine that Gaye chose to keep, and an accidental blend of two lead vocal takes by the engineers gave the record its famous doubled voice. Detroit Lions players Mel Farr and Lem Barney sang harmony on the title track. The first mix was finished on April 5, 1971; Gordy worried that it lacked a hit, and Gaye revised it at The Sound Factory in Los Angeles in early May, adding further vocals and instruments there on May 5.

Music and themes

Gaye conceived the album as a song cycle, its tracks joined by segues and returning musical ideas, with a loose story about a veteran who comes home from Vietnam to find his country in crisis. The sound draws on jazz, gospel and orchestral writing as much as on Motown soul: Latin percussion, lush strings, saxophone and Gaye's multi-tracked voices answering one another.

Side one opens with “What's Going On,” a mournful, jazz- and gospel-tinged plea for understanding between generations, and between protesters and the police. “What's Happening Brother,” dedicated to Frankie Gaye, voices a returning soldier's bewilderment at a changed home, and “Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky)” turns to heroin addiction. “Save the Children” asks listeners to protect the next generation, “God Is Love” is a short devotional interlude, and “Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)” is an early environmental lament, mourning poisoned air, water and land.

Side two begins with “Right On,” a seven-minute jam built on funk and Latin rhythms in which Gaye considers how differently people live and sets the power of love against hatred. “Wholy Holy” is a gospel call for unity, and “Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)” closes the record with a dark, spare blues-funk groove about urban poverty and frustration. Across the whole album, faith and protest are not opposites: the songs move between anger, grief and prayer without breaking the flow of the music.

Release

Tamla released What's Going On on May 21, 1971. The gatefold sleeve, with art direction by Curtis McNair, carries Jim Hendin's photographs of Gaye on the front and back covers, and the inside montage draws on the Gaye and Gordy family archives. The title track, issued on January 20, 1971, reached number two on the Hot 100 and spent five weeks at number one on the soul singles chart. “Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)” followed in June and reached number four, and “Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)” in September reached number nine; both also topped the rhythm and blues chart. “Save the Children” was released as a further single and reached number 41 in the UK. The album stayed on the Billboard chart for more than a year and sold about two million copies within twelve months.

Singles

SingleReleasedUKUS
“What's Going On”January 20, 1971—2
“Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)”June 10, 1971—4
“Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)”September 16, 1971—9
“Save the Children”November 11, 197141—

Reception

Reviews in 1971 were warm. Vince Aletti praised the album in Rolling Stone, Billboard heard in it a meeting of Curtis Mayfield and the Motown sound, and Time described it as a sweeping, melodic orchestral pop suite. Robert Christgau was cooler, faulting David Van De Pitte's string arrangements and grading the record B in The Village Voice and B+ in his later Record Guide. Rolling Stone placed it at the top of its year-end list, and the album earned Gaye two Grammy nominations at the 1972 ceremony.

Its reputation has only grown. The 40th anniversary edition of 2011 earned a perfect score of 100 on Metacritic, based on ten reviews, and later critics have treated the album as one of the high points of American popular music, praising its unity of sound and subject and the warmth of Gaye's layered vocal production.

Review scores

PublicationRating
Christgau's Record GuideB+
The Village VoiceB
Sputnikmusic5/5
Metacritic (2011 edition)100/100

Track listing

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
Side one
1“What's Going On”Gaye, Cleveland, Benson3:51
2“What's Happening Brother”Gaye, Nyx2:57
3“Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky)”Gaye3:40
4“Save the Children”Gaye, Cleveland, Benson3:04
5“God Is Love”Gaye, A. Gaye, Stover, Nyx2:31
6“Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)”Gaye3:05
Side two
7“Right On”Gaye, DeRouen7:20
8“Wholy Holy”Gaye, Benson, Cleveland3:20
9“Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)”Gaye, Nyx5:16
Total length35:04

Timings are those printed on the original 1971 US Tamla LP (TS-310), which add up to the side totals of 19:08 and 15:56; later CD editions list slightly different lengths. The 2002 remaster added an alternate version of “God Is Love” and the outtake “Sad Tomorrows,” and a deluxe edition with 28 additional tracks followed on May 31, 2011.

Personnel

Lead performer

  • Marvin Gaye: lead and background vocals, piano

Additional musicians

  • James Jamerson: bass
  • Bob Babbitt: bass
  • Max Janowsky: string bass
  • Chet Forest: drums
  • Joe Messina, Robert White: guitar
  • Jack Ashford: percussion, tambourine
  • Earl DeRouen, Eddie Brown: bongos, congas
  • Johnny Griffith: celesta
  • Carole Crosby: harp
  • Jack Brokensha: vibraphone
  • Eli Fontaine: alto saxophone
  • William “Wild Bill” Moore: tenor saxophone
  • Elgie Stover, Lem Barney, Mel Farr, the Andantes: background vocals
  • Detroit session horn, woodwind and string players

Production

  • Marvin Gaye: producer, liner notes
  • David Van De Pitte: arranger, conductor
  • Ed Wolfrum, Steve Smith, Kenneth Sands: engineering
  • Curtis McNair: art direction
  • Jim Hendin: photography

Charts and certifications

Weekly charts

ChartYearPeak
US Billboard 20019716
US Billboard Soul LPs19711
Canada (RPM)197137
UK Albums (OCC)199656
Ireland (IRMA)200664

Certifications

RegionCertificationUnits
United States (RIAA)Gold500,000
United Kingdom (BPI)Platinum300,000

Legacy

What's Going On is regularly named among the greatest albums ever recorded. Rolling Stone ranked it sixth on its 2003 list of the 500 greatest albums and first on the revised list of 2020; NME placed it first in 1985, and The Guardian did the same in 1997. It entered the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1998 and the Library of Congress National Recording Registry in 2003, and it is certified gold in the United States and platinum in the UK. By taking control of his own production Gaye opened the way for the self-produced albums Stevie Wonder made later in the 1970s, and Sly and the Family Stone's There's a Riot Goin' On, released six months later, was heard as a reply. The title song has ranked in the top ten of every edition of Rolling Stone's list of the greatest songs since 2004.

Accolades

PublicationAccoladeYearRank
Rolling StoneThe 500 Greatest Albums of All Time20036
Rolling StoneThe 500 Greatest Albums of All Time20201
NMEAll-time greatest albums19851
The Guardian100 Best Albums Ever19971
Library of CongressNational Recording Registry2003Inducted

In the Resonance

In the practice of Deep Listening, What's Going On is the record that teaches the faithful how to hear a whole album as one breath. It is made for the Dropping of the Needle, one side at a sitting, without skipping: the questions of the first song are still in the air when the last one fades, and the Signal is the conversation between them. Resonants turn to it in troubled seasons, not for answers, but for company in the asking.

Deep Listening
  1. What's Going OnSide one · track 1
    Listen for Eli Fontaine's unplanned alto saxophone at the start and for the two lead vocals that float slightly apart from each other.
  2. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)Side one · track 6
    Notice how gently the band plays under a song of real alarm, and listen for Wild Bill Moore's tenor saxophone in the closing minute.
  3. Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)Side two · track 3
    Follow the bass and percussion, which hold the whole song on a few low, patient figures while the strings darken around them.

Questions

When was What's Going On released?

On May 21, 1971, by Motown's Tamla label.

Who wrote the song “What's Going On”?

Marvin Gaye, Al Cleveland and Renaldo “Obie” Benson of the Four Tops.

Is What's Going On a concept album?

Yes. It is a song cycle whose tracks run into one another, loosely following a veteran returning home from Vietnam.

Where does What's Going On rank among the greatest albums?

Rolling Stone ranked it number one on its 2020 list of the 500 greatest albums of all time, after placing it sixth in 2003.

See also & references

References

  1. Wikipedia, What's Going On (album). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What%27s_Going_On_(album)
  2. Discogs, Marvin Gaye, What's Going On (Tamla TS-310, 1971). www.discogs.com/de/release/1559040-Marvin-Gaye-Whats-Going-On
  3. 45worlds, Marvin Gaye, What's Going On (Tamla TS 310). mail.45worlds.com/vinyl/album/t310
  4. Wikipedia, Marvin Gaye discography. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marvin_Gaye_discography
  5. Wikipedia, Marvin Gaye. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marvin_Gaye

Hear the Signal?

Membership of The Resonance is free. It always will be.

Become a Resonant

The Holy Church of Rock honors Marvin Gaye among the Attuned. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by or connected to Marvin Gaye, its members, their estates, record labels or publishers. Names are used to identify the music we write about. No lyrics or cover artwork are reproduced on this site.