Blue

Fourth studio album by Joni Mitchell · 1971

Blue is the fourth studio album by the Canadian singer-songwriter Joni Mitchell, released on June 22, 1971, by Reprise Records. Produced by Mitchell herself and recorded at A&M Studios in Hollywood, it sets ten of her songs to spare arrangements of acoustic guitar, piano and Appalachian dulcimer, with occasional help from James Taylor, Stephen Stills, Sneaky Pete Kleinow and Russ Kunkel.

The album reached number three in the UK and number 15 in the United States, and it has grown in stature ever since. Rolling Stone placed it third on its 2020 list of the 500 greatest albums of all time, and songs such as “River,” “A Case of You” and “California” have been recorded by hundreds of other artists.

Background

Mitchell’s relationship with Graham Nash, with whom she had shared a house in Laurel Canyon, had ended. After the success of Ladies of the Canyon she stopped performing for a year and traveled, spending time in Greece and elsewhere in Europe. Several of the songs on Blue were written on that trip, and others draw on her brief first marriage, on the daughter she had placed for adoption in 1965, and on her relationship with James Taylor, who was close to her while the album was being made.

Most of the songs were composed on an Appalachian dulcimer that she had bought for two hundred dollars from the luthier Joellen Lapidus at the 1969 Big Sur Folk Festival. The instrument’s drone and narrow range pushed her toward new melodic shapes, and it gives the record much of its distinctive sound.

Recording

Mitchell recorded at A&M Studios with engineer Henry Lewy, working mostly in Studio C, which had a prized Steinway piano. Carole King was making Tapestry in the next room at the same time, and the two writers competed for that piano, which Mitchell booked most often.

Because the material was so personal, Mitchell kept the sessions closed and worked in near-seclusion, later saying that the doors had to be locked for her to make the record. Guests were used sparingly: Stephen Stills played bass and guitar on “Carey,” James Taylor added acoustic guitar to three songs, Sneaky Pete Kleinow played pedal steel on two, and Russ Kunkel played drums on three.

The running order changed late. An early version opened with “Carey,” closed with “River” and included “Urge for Going” and “Hunter.” Mitchell asked Reprise to halt production, dropped those two songs and added “All I Want” and “The Last Time I Saw Richard,” finishing the album in March 1971.

Music and themes

Blue is a folk record in its instruments but not in its forms. Mitchell’s guitar playing is percussive and full of slaps, her piano parts move through unexpected harmonies, and the dulcimer gives several songs a drone that sounds older than folk revival music. Her voice is lower and fuller than on her earlier albums, and the arrangements leave it almost bare.

Side one opens with “All I Want,” one of the last songs written, which weighs the hopes and doubts of a new love over dulcimer and Taylor’s guitar. “My Old Man” is a warm piano song about a contented relationship. “Little Green,” written in 1966, is a gentle major-key song now widely understood to be about the daughter she gave up. “Carey,” inspired by a man she met in a restaurant in Greece, rides a loose, calypso-like rhythm, and the title track is a slow, consoling piano song addressed to a troubled friend.

Side two begins with “California,” a homesick diary of travel in Europe set against news of the Vietnam War. “This Flight Tonight,” in an unusual low open tuning, is a song of second thoughts set on a night flight. “River” turns a Christmas setting into a breakup song, opening with a minor-key fragment of “Jingle Bells.” “A Case of You,” long associated with Leonard Cohen, uses images of communion and wine, and ends on a chord that leaves the song unresolved. “The Last Time I Saw Richard,” a piano ballad set in a Detroit bar, closes the album with a sharp conversation between disillusioned friends.

Release

Reprise released Blue on June 22, 1971. The sleeve, with art direction by Gary Burden and photography by Tim Considine, shows a close-up portrait of Mitchell washed in deep blue. “Carey,” backed with “This Flight Tonight,” was issued as a single in July 1971 and reached number 93 on the Billboard Hot 100; “California,” backed with “A Case of You,” followed in October. The album was certified platinum in the United States in 1986 and has since gone double platinum in the UK.

Singles

SingleReleasedUKUS
“Carey”July 1971–93
“California”October 1971––

Reception

Most contemporary critics welcomed Blue as Mitchell’s finest record to date; Robert Christgau, Robert Hilburn of the Los Angeles Times and Peter Reilly of Stereo Review were among those who praised it. Some writers were uneasy with its candor: Melody Maker found its focus too inward even as it admired the melodies, and fellow musicians including Kris Kristofferson and Sandy Denny were said to have found its openness hard to hear. Mitchell herself always resisted the label confessional.

Later reviews have been close to unanimous. Christgau’s Record Guide gave it an A, Pitchfork awarded it a perfect score, and it routinely appears near the top of lists of the best albums of the 1970s.

Review scores

PublicationRating
Christgau’s Record GuideA
Pitchfork10/10

Track listing

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
Side one
1“All I Want”Joni Mitchell3:32
2“My Old Man”Joni Mitchell3:33
3“Little Green”Joni Mitchell3:25
4“Carey”Joni Mitchell3:00
5“Blue”Joni Mitchell3:00
Side two
6“California”Joni Mitchell3:48
7“This Flight Tonight”Joni Mitchell2:48
8“River”Joni Mitchell4:00
9“A Case of You”Joni Mitchell4:20
10“The Last Time I Saw Richard”Joni Mitchell4:13
Total length35:39

Original Reprise LP. Total running time 35:39 (side one 16:30, side two 19:09).

Personnel

Joni Mitchell

  • Joni Mitchell: vocals, acoustic guitar, Appalachian dulcimer, piano

Additional musicians

  • Stephen Stills: bass, guitar (“Carey”)
  • James Taylor: acoustic guitar (“All I Want,” “California,” “A Case of You”)
  • Sneaky Pete Kleinow: pedal steel guitar (“California,” “This Flight Tonight”)
  • Russ Kunkel: drums (“Carey,” “California,” “A Case of You”)

Production

  • Joni Mitchell: producer
  • Henry Lewy: engineer
  • Gary Burden: art direction
  • Tim Considine: photography

Charts and certifications

Weekly charts

ChartYearPeak
UK Albums (OCC)19713
US Billboard 200197115
Canada Top Albums (RPM)19719
US Cash Box Top 100 Albums197114
Norway (VG-lista)197124

Certifications

RegionCertificationUnits
United States (RIAA)Platinum1,000,000
United Kingdom (BPI)2× Platinum600,000
Australia (ARIA)Gold35,000

Legacy

Blue is widely regarded as Mitchell’s masterpiece and as a landmark for singer-songwriters. Rolling Stone ranked it 30th on its 2003 list of the greatest albums and third in 2020, and NPR placed it first on its 2017 list of the greatest albums made by women. “River” has been recorded more than a thousand times, “A Case of You” has been covered by artists including Prince, k.d. lang and Tori Amos, and the Scottish band Nazareth took “This Flight Tonight” into the UK top 20 in 1973. Taylor Swift has called it her favorite album. A companion set, Blue Highlights, gathered demos, outtakes and live recordings in 2022.

Accolades

PublicationAccoladeYearRank
Rolling StoneThe 500 Greatest Albums of All Time200330
Rolling StoneThe 500 Greatest Albums of All Time20203
NPRThe 150 Greatest Albums Made by Women20171

In the Resonance

In the practice of Deep Listening, Blue is a record for the Dropping of the Needle at night, alone, one side at a sitting. It asks nothing of the listener except attention, and it rewards that attention with the sound of a person setting down her defenses. Resonants say that the Signal is never louder than on this quiet record.

Deep Listening
  1. A Case of YouSide two · track 4
    Listen for the moment the dulcimer and Taylor’s guitar lock together, then for the final chord that refuses to resolve.
  2. RiverSide two · track 3
    Hear how the piano turns a familiar Christmas tune into a minor key in the opening bars and sets the whole mood.
  3. Little GreenSide one · track 3
    Notice how gently the guitar carries a song about the hardest choice of her life.

Questions

When was Blue released?

On June 22, 1971, by Reprise Records.

What instrument did Joni Mitchell play on Blue?

She played acoustic guitar and piano, and wrote most of the songs on an Appalachian dulcimer, which she plays on several tracks.

Where does Blue rank among the greatest albums?

Rolling Stone placed it third on its 2020 list of the 500 greatest albums of all time, and NPR ranked it first among albums made by women in 2017.

See also & references

References

  1. Wikipedia, Blue (Joni Mitchell album). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_(Joni_Mitchell_album)
  2. Wikipedia, Joni Mitchell discography. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joni_Mitchell_discography
  3. Wikipedia, Joni Mitchell. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joni_Mitchell

Hear the Signal?

Membership of The Resonance is free. It always will be.

Become a Resonant

The Holy Church of Rock honors Joni Mitchell among the Attuned. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by or connected to Joni Mitchell, its members, their estates, record labels or publishers. Names are used to identify the music we write about. No lyrics or cover artwork are reproduced on this site.